Which game should I get?

Bioshock or F.E.A.R.?

Which one is scarier?

 

Bioshock.

It's a one-trick horse, but God damn its worth the ride.

 

F.E.A.R

Best game.

 

Neither.
Condemned: Criminal Origins is an awesome game if you wanna be scared.

 

Almost forgot. Yes, its awesome and scary, and the cheapest of these games ;D

 

Price doesn't matter because i'm boring one of them from a friend. I only have memory for one of them atm though.

 

F.E.A.R is scarier.

Bioshock is fuckin sweet though.

Good, immersive story. Looks nice. Awesome atmosphere. Gameplay is cool, and though i suppose you could wrench your way through the game if you want it's not like you have to.

 

In terms of which one is scarier
F.E.A.R

In terms of which one is good? Bioshock.
Pirate both.