Discussion in 'Competitions' started by Inasuma, May 5, 2007.
SotW #13 - Voting
You know the drill. Vote your top 3.
I like Cin's.
It has really nice effects, such as the text and flow.
I vote Cin as well. His flow and effects are very nice--though the style is old. :P
I vote for Cin, too. xD
Very sexy. <3
Misty gets my vote!
My vote goes to Misty.
Very hard choice. Vote goes to Misty.
My vote goes to -Sharp> I really like the coloring and patterns. Misty's was good too.
Man this is ridiculous lol
Vote 1: Sharp
Vote 2: Milkman
Vote 3: Cin
haha oh wow. No one except C4E posted their vote properly.
the rules say VOTE YOUR TOP 3. And i suggest that all members give a proper reason for their votes, And that in future SotW's that only those that actually do GFX make a vote, to prevent silly biased stuffs.
I'll vote later.
1. Sharp - Lovely colors and affects, nice depth. Though the top isn't amazing, and neither is the text, sharp gets my vote because it just seems like the best sig of the bunch.
2. Myself...;P - I truthfully am looking at this fromt he perspective of someone who didn't make the sig. I really like it, lots of flow, great text. Colors and lighting are iffy, but not huge problems. I agree with Darky, the style is getting old. TRY SOMETHING NEW CIN!! JEEZ!!! DX
3. Milkman - Iffy colors, but nice affects, Goddaluv a Milky sig. I like the solid background the most.
Good luck everyone!
I don't think its right to vote for yourself.
I think this set of rules is good:
1. No voting for self.
2. Only those with Satisfactory Art/Graphic knowledge may cast a vote
3.Give proper reasons for each tag vote.
4. All contestants must submit a vote or be disqualified (just to add that extra spark to the competition ;)
1. thefallen: Amazing colors, Depth is lacking, as is flow.. But really, Who needs flow and depth when you have an artistic masterpiece? You got my number one spot dude.
2. MistyMighty: Nice use of negative space, Though the tag lacks the vibrancy of Thefallens, It really catches my eye and deserves my Number 2 spot.
3. Sharp: I really don't dig this tag, but it takes thirg place in my vote cause i dont like Cin's and I can't vote for myself. Flow is messed up, everything is generic and cliche about it.
I voted for myself, because...well...I don't really like anyone elses. XD
Besides, the vote won't count, what's the big deal?
It's more of the idea of it looking unprofessional, Cin. :/ You may like yours more, but at least critique another signature. Lol.
Hm... I'm going to vote Milkman because it's simple, yet stylish. The colors aren't the greatest and the render is a bit over sharpened, but by far sticks out the most to me.
Good luck to everyone else!
Well, what do you know, Misty wins! =P
Great job, all of you. See you for next weeks SotW! :)