If card cannot be accepted in random, in most of cases it gives even more reasons to not accept it for non-random. Only exception would be card like "Seventh One", but even stronger. Plus Joker, Rabin and Buttman are still broke as hell.
There is that one spell card in anime, that allows you to play one trap from hand. It requires you to pay cost of one card from your hand, when your Joker does not. Its enough to say that something is wrong, when anime card is more balanced than your custom. There is also Bubble Illusion that requires you to use more cards than this card and is not repetitive effect that can happen every turn. Also there is Anime exclusive Rubble King that have the same effect that activates traps from your hand... but is 0/0 monster with activation requirement of having 30 cards in your graveyard. Joker you made is not only cheating towards cards that exist in game and are legal, but also towards Anime cards. And since you never said in what exact format you want them to be accepted, it gets no for every card that have similar effect and is more balanced.[DOUBLEPOST=1424608963][/DOUBLEPOST] Orichalcos Tokens cannot OTK. But its still a deck. So I think that proves your argument invalid.
No Jaden I cannot be polite with both of you. Because if I would be polite it nothing would go trough your thick head. Think of me being polite towards you as a reward, not like its your right, because it isn't. Because 2 cards you presented hold as much OTK value as Blackwings do, and I wonder what will happen when you actually manage to make them an archetype. From other 2, that are in no way VH, make combination more broken than anything we have in game. Even new versions that I didn't have time to go through completely are broken as hell. And please do not compare existing archetypes to your at best series of cards, without understanding how they work. And I don't believe you know how they work. After all, you cannot keep up with real game in any way, to extend to extend that makes you not being able to accept changes in game.
Well I'm not stopping you from submitting them. I however am in right to demand from you to use proper terms. And high standards are always good thing for balance, so I take it as compliment. EDIT: Funny thing is that my standards are pretty low from what they should be. If I used my high standards, well it would be fun... but only for me.
It may sounds cooler, but is not proper term outside of China, so **** it.
You are allowed to make good cards, not broken ones. And its already sucky archetype, because its not archetype at all. AND KONAMI CAN MAKE ALL THE BROKEN CARDS, BUT AT LEAST THEY BALANCE THEM IN SOME WAY BEFORE RELEASING. I DON'T SEE YOU BALANCING THEM ENOUGH TO LEVEL THEY ARE NOT JUST PLAIN CHEATING IN MOST OF CASES. ALSO KONAMI OWNS THE GAME OF YU-GI-OH. THEY CAN DO ANY CARDS THEY WANT. IF YOU HAPPEN TO OWN THIS GAME THEN YOU HAVE MY PERMISSION TO MAKE ALL BROKEN CUSTOMS YOU WANT. BUT IF NOT, THEN LIKE HELL YOU CAN! eh.. I really hope that all this writing in caps was worth it and certain somebody understood something... probably not... Its a big deal because they break balance of game itself presenting AV model. Absolute Victory is situation, when card that is vastly superior to others is released in game. Long story short, in the end everybody would play card that fits AV model, causing game to become pure game of luck with one deck used, with the one that wins being player that plays AV card first. In arena, one to play AV card first is always first player, making going second (that is already hard task when your opponent knows what he is doing) impossible task.[DOUBLEPOST=1424549068][/DOUBLEPOST] I did phase that wrong. I meant its the same meaning he meant (at least I hope he meant). Well with "This card can not be used for a Synchro Summon or Exceed Summon." its just (almost) useless piece of text that makes card harder to read. Proper one would be cannot in this case if it was to restrict something. If not, then again, whats a point in having this part of effect, except to counter that one card (that may not exist at all)?
Why do I feel like there will be shitton of OGG errors and brokenness involved? Oh maybe that's why? For beginning, there is no such thing as Exceed Summon, unless you play in China if I remember correctly. Second why are you keep using "can not" instead "cannot"? Meaning is the same in both cases and it only takes more space in card text (also looks ugly as hell for some reason). Also those effects did not changed in way that would make them more balanced, and adding equip card during DP is pretty much so meh that only thing saving Rabin is its SS.
Do you think that effect that makes you go +1 and your opponent -1 every once per turn just because you control monster that can inflict damage and can be special summoned without hard to meet condition is balanced? If yes, then there is no hope for you. As for buttman, he have way to many positive effects as for LVL 4 monster that can Special Summon itself with easy to meet condition.
It doesn't matter if it reveals hand or not. It takes one of your opponent cards out of their hand, without cost, or condition that must be meet to do so. It can be special summoned, by having monster that can protect it (or if you control it you can special summon such monster). And its only level 4 with relatively high stats as for its effect. For beginning I will stand with my resolve and give them my no automatically when they are presented in way that makes them harder to judge. Having to scroll every time to see their effects is annoying, and in result makes it harder to judge. You can always present them with cards effects in form of text, that just allows me to copy them and don't care how it looks. Then, I suggest completely remodeling effect of Joker. Its too cheap to be accepted even as anime/manga exclusive. As for Harley it could stand this way, if not for obviously broken effect of Joker. Robin can open some nasty OTK with him adding any equip spell card. You should probably change it to one specific equip spell card, that doesn't open so many nasty OTK. As with Buttman you should get rid off his negating ability/trap destruction ability. Right now its Wildman+++.
Let me give you two pieces of information: 1st auto denial out of really obvious reason I explained before. Lets have some aesthetic standards here. Also putting them next to each other makes it easier. 2nd Joker is still broke as hell.
Thats even worse.
Last one is second Rabin.
Same case as with other guy, putting them in one line doesn't hurt you and it makes my eyes to not hurt. Also checking links you add also doesn't hurt too. Anyway, as with SmokeBomb, they get auto denial until you put them in way that doesn't makes me scroll every time I need to check if one card can combo well with other.
Okay I would be somewhat OK with those effects, but I still probably would change some of them. Only one I completely remodeled is Assemble. Thoughts? Spoiler: Effects Avengers Assemble (Changes with effect + changes with type to Continuous Spell card): While this card is face-up on the field, you can activate this effect instead of conducting a normal draw during your Draw Phase. Special Summon 1 "Thor" OR "Hulk" OR "Iron Man" OR "Captain America" OR "Hawkeye" OR "Black Widow" from your Hand or Deck. You can only control 1 "Avengers Assemble". Black Widow (OGG edits + changes with effect): If your opponent controls a monster and you control no monsters, you can Special Summon this card (from your hand). When this card is Summoned this way, you can add 1 "Hawkeye" from Deck to your hand. You can only use this effect of "Black Widow" once per Duel. Hawkeye (OGG edits + changes with effect): If your opponent controls a monster and you control no monsters, you can Special Summon this card (from your hand). When this card is Summoned this way, you can add 1 "Black Widow" from Deck to your hand. You can only use this effect of "Hawkeye" once per Duel. Captain America (OGG edits + changes with effect + changes with stats to (2000/0)): When this card destroys an opponent's monster by battle: Place 1 Patriot Counter on this card. If this card would be destroyed by battle: You can remove 1 Patriot Counter instead. If this card attacks, it is changed to Defense Position at the end of the Battle Phase, and its battle position cannot be changed until the End Phase of your next turn. Hulk (OGG edits): When this card destroys an opponent's monster by battle: Place 1 Rage Counter on this card. This card gains 200 ATK for each Rage Counter on it. If this card would be destroyed, you can remove 1 Rage Counter instead. Iron Man (OGG edits + changes with effect): When this card destroys an opponent's monster by battle: Place 1 Iron Counter on this card. This card gains 100 ATK for each Iron Counter on it. You can remove 3 Iron Counters from this card: Your opponent discards 1 card. This card cannot attack during the turn you use this effect. Thor (OGG edits): When this card destroys an opponent's monster by battle: Place 1 Thunder Counter on this card. Once per turn: you can remove 1 Thunder Counter to destroy 1 Spell/Trap Card on the field. This card cannot attack during the turn you use this effect. OROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROROR
As it stands now it would be SS one, you get to SS 2nd. Xyz into Constellar Ptolemy M7, Gauntlet Launcher or even Number 25: Force Focus, get rid of something problematic and if OLD Assemble would be legal SS 8100 damage onto board. Well with new assemble you can always destroy your own monster and get 8100 damage. But it would need to be legal.[DOUBLEPOST=1424487390][/DOUBLEPOST] 1st its good enough so I will start to judge them fairly. 2nd ehh.... I didn't wanted to do it, but can you post effects of all Avenger ones in form of text? If you do I will try to edit them so I would be fine with them.
And I just realized I completely forgot about them SS themselves even if your opponent does not control anything. Even more reasons to not accept them. Nice catch.[DOUBLEPOST=1424486299][/DOUBLEPOST] You click big image button between smiley face and videos and insert link. Then you do it again without pressing enter key. Repeat until you inserted all cards in post. EDIT: Or of you use BB codes you can do something like this: [IMG.]link to img[/IMG.][IMG.]link to img2[/IMG.][IMG.]link to img3[/IMG.]ect.
All unaccepted (even those I accepted before). Is it really that hard to place them next to each other?
It was normal spell before and had the same requirement to be activated before. And it was SS from Deck before (not sure if from hand too, so I will trust you on this one). Just gonna say that it first part is completely useless, because its a Normal Spell for some time right now. As for the rest they get my automatic no for reason stated before.
Ah OK, I haven't noticed that one. That makes only assemble not being a reprint.
